Black Friday: 20% off everything 0d 00h 00m 00s Shop the sale →

Conflict Resolution at Work: A 5-Step Process, Scripts and Examples for Managers

Free Resources › Performance

Conflict resolution at work is the process of bringing a disagreement between colleagues into the open, understanding what each person actually needs, and agreeing a specific way forward. Disagreement about the work is normal and often useful. The manager's job is to keep it about the work, and to step in early when it turns personal.

The short version: first decide whether it's a task conflict (a disagreement about the work) or an ego conflict (it's become personal). Let task conflict run, with some structure. For ego conflict, act within days: meet each person separately, listen without interrupting, stay impartial, find the need underneath each position, then bring them together to agree actions, owners and a date to review.

Task conflict vs ego conflict

Researchers such as Karen Jehn have long separated conflict about the work from conflict between people. The distinction matters because the two need opposite responses.

Task conflict Ego conflict
What it's about The plan, the priority, the approach, the facts Status, respect, blame, who gets credit
What it sounds like "I think option B is lower risk, and here's why." "She always does this." "He's undermining me."
Effect on the team Better decisions, fewer blind spots Silence, side-taking, work routed around people
What you do Encourage it, give it a time and a decision-maker Step in quickly and resolve it using the process below

Patrick Lencioni put it well: "When there is trust, conflict becomes nothing but the pursuit of truth, an attempt to find the best possible answer." A team with no visible conflict usually isn't harmonious. It's just quiet.

A 5-step conflict resolution process for managers

This is the process on the Conflict Resolution card in The Leader's Toolkit, with what each step looks like in practice.

  1. Act promptly and make it safe. Raise it within days, not at the next review. If emotions are high, meet each person separately first. "I've noticed things have been tense between you and Sam on the launch. I'd like to hear your side, privately."
  2. Let each person explain without interruption. Ask what happened and how it has affected them, then listen. Use active listening: summarise what you heard before you respond. "So the main issue is that the scope changed without anyone telling you?"
  3. Stay impartial. Ask what happened rather than assuming you know. Don't agree with either side in the separate meetings, even if one account sounds more convincing. You will be quoted.
  4. Find the need underneath. People argue about positions ("I need sign-off on every change") but the fix is in the interest behind it ("I keep getting blamed when the numbers are wrong"). This idea comes from Roger Fisher and William Ury's Getting to Yes. Once you can see both interests, a solution is usually obvious.
  5. Agree a resolution plan. Bring them together. Agree specific actions, who owns each one and a date to review. Write it down in a short note to both. Then actually check in on that date.

What to say at each stage

Moment Try
Opening the separate conversation "I'm not here to decide who's right. I want to understand what's going on from your side."
When they generalise "Can you give me a recent example? What happened, and when?"
Getting to the need "If this were sorted, what would be different for you?"
Opening the joint conversation "You both want the launch to go well. You disagree on how. Let's lay out what each of you needs, then work out a plan."
When it heats up "Let's pause. I want to make sure we're talking about the work, not each other."
Closing "So: Ana sends scope changes in writing by Wednesday, Tom flags concerns before the stand-up, and we'll review in two weeks. Is that right?"

5 workplace conflict resolution strategies

The Thomas-Kilmann model, developed by Kenneth Thomas and Ralph Kilmann, describes five ways people handle conflict. None is always right. Good managers choose deliberately.

  • Collaborating. Work together to meet both sets of needs. Best for important issues where both people will keep working together. Takes the most time.
  • Compromising. Each side gives something up. Useful when time is short and a good-enough answer will do.
  • Competing. One view wins. Right for urgent calls, safety issues or decisions that are yours to make. Explain why.
  • Accommodating. One person lets the other have it. Fine when the issue matters far more to one side, but watch for the same person always giving way.
  • Avoiding. Leave it for now. Occasionally sensible when tempers need to cool. As a habit, it's how small conflicts become big ones.

6 conflict resolution examples at work

Situation What's often underneath A resolution that works
Two people both think they own the client relationship Unclear roles Agree in writing who owns what, and tell the client. Fix the delegation or role gap so it doesn't recur.
A senior engineer rewrites a junior's work without asking Different quality standards, no review process Agree a review step and what "done" means. Ask the senior to explain changes rather than make them.
Sales and operations blame each other for missed delivery dates Incentives pulling in opposite directions Look at what each team is rewarded for. Agree one shared measure and a handover rule.
One person keeps talking over another in meetings Different communication styles Give feedback to the interrupter privately. Run meetings with a round so everyone speaks.
A team splits over a change to the rota People feel the decision was made without them Explain the reasoning, take objections openly, then make the call and ask the team to disagree and commit.
Two colleagues have stopped speaking after a public argument Embarrassment, a need to save face Meet each separately, then together. Focus on how they'll work together from here, not on re-running the argument.

12 questions to ask in a conflict conversation

  1. What happened, from your point of view?
  2. When did this start?
  3. Can you give me a specific example?
  4. How has it affected your work?
  5. What do you think they would say if I asked them?
  6. What matters most to you here?
  7. What would a good outcome look like?
  8. What part of this is within your control?
  9. What are you willing to do differently?
  10. What do you need from them?
  11. What do you need from me?
  12. How will we know it's working?

How to prevent conflict before it starts

  • Regular check-ins. Most conflicts show up early in 1:1s if you ask how working relationships are going.
  • Clear roles and expectations. Overlapping ownership is the most common cause of ego conflict that starts as a task problem.
  • Check the incentives. If two people are rewarded for opposite outcomes, they will clash, however well they get on.
  • Look at the whole team. A team health check surfaces group-level tension one person won't raise alone.

Common mistakes

  • Waiting for it to blow over. Personal conflict rarely does. The rest of the team is watching how long you leave it.
  • Taking sides in the first conversation. Whoever reaches you first isn't necessarily right.
  • Going straight to a joint meeting. If emotions are high, separate conversations first stop it becoming a repeat of the original argument.
  • Trying to stop all disagreement. Shutting down task conflict gives you a quiet team and worse decisions.
  • Ending without actions. "Let's all try to get on" isn't a plan. Owners and a review date are.
  • Ignoring a pattern. If the same person is in every conflict, it may be a toxic team mate issue rather than a series of disagreements.
The Leader's Toolkit leadership card deck for managers

Conflict Resolution is 1 of 52 tools in The Leader's Toolkit

Every tool on this site comes from The Leader's Toolkit: 52 practical tools on 54 cards for 1:1s, feedback, delegation, retention and team problems, each linked to the tools that work with it. Keep the whole system on your desk instead of in browser tabs.

Get The Leader's ToolkitBrowse all free tools

FAQs

What is conflict resolution at work?

It's the process of bringing a workplace disagreement into the open, understanding what each person needs and agreeing specific actions to move forward. For managers, it also means telling the difference between healthy disagreement about the work and personal conflict that needs stepping in on.

What are the 5 steps of conflict resolution?

Act promptly and create a safe space; let each person explain without interruption; stay impartial and ask rather than assume; identify the underlying needs; and agree a resolution plan with actions, owners and a review date.

What are the 5 conflict resolution strategies?

The Thomas-Kilmann model lists collaborating, compromising, competing, accommodating and avoiding. Each fits different situations. Collaborating takes longest but works best when the issue matters and people will keep working together.

Should a manager meet both people together or separately?

Usually separately first, especially if emotions are high. It lets each person speak freely and gives you the full picture. Then bring them together to agree the way forward.

When should you involve HR in a workplace conflict?

Straight away if it involves harassment, discrimination, threats or anything that may break policy or law. Otherwise, involve HR if the conflict continues after you've tried to resolve it, or before any formal step.